check out the new remote control Jockey Wheel SmartBar Topargee products Enginesaver Low Water Alarms Red Earth Festival Hammervan Park Booker
Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
Post Info TOPIC: 3 WAY OR COMPRESSOR FRIDGE? UPDATE PLEASE


Senior Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 248
Date:
3 WAY OR COMPRESSOR FRIDGE? UPDATE PLEASE


I know this has been discussed many times but we are about to set off on the "big lap" We purchased our 2nd hand van with a 12/240 compressor fridge newly installed and was given the former 3 way fridge as well. We use the 3 way on the patio as a bar fridge and it works like magic. With all the talk about having enough solar + batteries to cope with free camping I am wondering are the 3 ways that bad to change to a fridge that needs so much power instead of using the gas?

Kim



__________________


Senior Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 358
Date:

Hi Kim,

We have a new van, 210 ltr Evercool 12v Platinum fridge. We mostly free camp and the power draw on the new compressor fridges are very efficient.

Ours is also wired through the trailer plug so fridge remains on when driving.

Also safer than the 3 way.

3 way running on batteries will flatten battery real quick.


__________________

Kevin Kyle

On the road full time with Son and 21 year old cat and 3 year old Manx.

Toyota Landcruiser 100 series V8.  Nextgen semi off-roader.  3 120 AH agm batteries, 1KW Solar



Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 2925
Date:

We have had the 12v fridge on throughout the Christmas break, the electrics are keeping up quite well. Its winter and the bad weather days when you may want to consider a back-up of some sort. I am just trying to set up while we have a home and facilities before we sell and move out. A three way fridge lessens the dependency on power, but where's your adventures spirit.
We free camped for a week during winter, bad weather and overcast, and we were really counting the amps. Would not have lasted much longer.
I'm now checking out flexible solar panels as a back up, less weight, less room.

__________________


Senior Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 216
Date:

Hi Kim, we have had both types of fridge and our currant van has a vitrifrigo compressor fridge. Works just like fridge at home, 3 to 4 degrees in fridge and minus 18 to 20 in freezer in Darwin with temp of 37 degrees.

Keeps ice cream frozen, something we could never do with a 3 way fridge.

We would never go back to a 3 way. But you have to be able to keep power available, I see that you have 240 volts as well as 12 volts, you can always go on power if weather is bad for long period of time, you have the best of choices. Stay with the compressor. You may also find that the 3 way might not fit through door, not good if you ever need service.

Barry

__________________
100 Series Turbo Cruiser & 21ft Lotus Trackvan


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 3066
Date:

Solar and 12\24\240v fridge go together like chalk and cheese.
WHAT.. is the make of 12\240 compressor fridge?

They "normally" a huge difference in power consumption to the 3 ways.

Waeco probably the best.
More efficient than Vitrifrigo. Same compressor. better insulation apparently.

I always get some1\4-3\8ths Styrene sheeting, (coupla, three layers to suit)
and line fridge area first for extra insulation.
Does make a difference. Just leave breathing space open.

You'll need a coupla 120w panels min, to run though.
with one or more 100a Battery's.
More panels down South.
My whole van sans Air Cond, ran on 340w panels and 2 x 100a Battery's
All over Aust.
WITH genny for backup rarely usedbut always there.

My last 3 vans I threw 3 ways in bin and changed.
They that good.

latest van just a local short hauler.
3 way IN van. Came with it.
80ltr Waeco in tray of ute with panel on roof of ute
and van too.

Some old fashioned ones stick by them though.
But if you have solar and\or genny I can't see why.

10 times MORE efficient in the hotter climes and used regularly.
Proven by thousands.

PS.
Removal of the bigger fridges is "normally" a window removal job.
Have fun.

They normally make a decent garage 240 fridge though.
Forget gas and battery. They suck.

__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 743
Date:

Hi Snippy(Kevin)

We also have new van with Evakool 210lt, Question! How noisy is your fridge? Can it be heard running easily or is it fairly silent.

thanks
Ian



__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 3066
Date:

Wanda.

IF they noisy.
TRY to lift a little from centre and put some rubber sheeting or feet under existing feet.
Separation\Insulation from vibration.

In extreme. a mate had a large fridge. Shook you out of bed some nights (literally)
He couldn't place cushioning under.
So he located the feet position From UNDER the van (Accurate measurements X 50.)
Then cut (hole cutter on drill) 4 holes corresponding to feet.

Made 4 LARGE plates with H\Duty rubber sheeting blocks, depth to suit.
and placed. Jacked up and set bolted all the way round each one
. with epoxy on faces.

Complex 'ish. Maybe a little.
But simple and cheap.
did job and after several yrs touring. Still good sleep at nights.

__________________


Senior Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 358
Date:

Wanda wrote:

Hi Snippy(Kevin)

We also have new van with Evakool 210lt, Question! How noisy is your fridge? Can it be heard running easily or is it fairly silent.

thanks
Ian


 Hi Ian,

First couple of days with the van, running off the the 1 crap battery that came with the van, compressor kept making popping noises and was quite noisy.

With the system we now have (see my signature) problem solved.  If a compressor fridge is noisy, make sure it is getting enough power.  Also make sure your van is level.  Nonetheless you will still here it running but only just.

Household fridges can be damaged by voltage drop (Brownout) but these 12volt van fridges seem to be able to take it.  My IT company used to  do insurance clain work for a few of the majors and brownout was a big issue then  (10 years ago)



__________________

Kevin Kyle

On the road full time with Son and 21 year old cat and 3 year old Manx.

Toyota Landcruiser 100 series V8.  Nextgen semi off-roader.  3 120 AH agm batteries, 1KW Solar



Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 2689
Date:

macka17 wrote:



They normally make a decent garage 240 fridge though.

Forget gas and battery. They suck.



For someone who is supposedly so knowledgeable re everything caravanning, I'm surprised that you don't know that 3 way fridges work better on gas than on 240v.

__________________
Bill B


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 7642
Date:

Our little 60l has a low voltage drop out breaker . Good as it doesn't completely drain the battery or kill the compressor motor .. Must say since increasing the standard wire size as I lengthened the lead . It doesn't trip as often . The leads are made to almost minimum spec !

__________________
Whats out there


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 6217
Date:

Bill B wrote:
macka17 wrote:



They normally make a decent garage 240 fridge though.

Forget gas and battery. They suck.

 



For someone who is supposedly so knowledgeable re everything caravanning, I'm surprised that you don't know that 3 way fridges work better on gas than on 240v.


 lol, ha ha. biggrin

Aussie Paul. smile



__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 3066
Date:

Yes Paul.

But I was talking AS HE IS USING IT. IN garage.
Most have leccytric not gas in garage.
I think??

Plus. After a coupla yrs at it.
I Personally have relegated last 3 of those things to the tip.

You can't sell much second hand here. It's a coastal and a mining town.
Too much money floating around.

Pity it don't float our way hey......

__________________


Senior Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 180
Date:

We too have an Evakool 110L plarinum and have just completed a 7month trip to all mainland states. Thr fridge is in a Transit campervan and we do have a Redarc 40A DC-DC charger and 2 new AGM batteries (or they were when we left home) of 120AH each. These are charged by 120W portable solar panels when we are camped. Our estimated demand is 55-60AH/day.

The longest time we stayed in one place was 7 days and the number of times we used the DC-DC charger to help the solar would have been less than 2 hours. Most of our camping was at unpowered sites and when we did stay at powered sites it was because we wanted AC, not to charge the batteries. We did experience a lot of consecutive mid 30s days.Unless we have sustained bad weather we reckon we are self-sufficient, but your power needs might be significantly greater.

You mention that the compressor fridge was installed to replace the 3 way one. That suggests that someone else preferred compressor fridges.

__________________

BJC

"A year from now you'll wish you had started today."

msg


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 1785
Date:

Sorry to go off topic,

In transit  .....
I have a transit (2008). It has 2x70ah under the passenger front seat. Is there room under the seat to upgrade to 2x120AH?

Thanks



__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 743
Date:

Thanks Kevin(snippy)

Yes van was/is level, fridge on its own circuit so power should be Ok.

What setting is your fridge set on with normal temps say around mid 20s?. Ours has to be on about 5 before it cools below 4deg!

regards

Ian

(hope I have not gone tooo far off topic people)



__________________


Senior Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 358
Date:

Wanda wrote:

Thanks Kevin(snippy)

Yes van was/is level, fridge on its own circuit so power should be Ok.

What setting is your fridge set on with normal temps say around mid 20s?. Ours has to be on about 5 before it cools below 4deg!

regards

Ian

(hope I have not gone tooo far off topic people)


 Same here, 5 on cooler days, 6 when it's a bit warmer.



__________________

Kevin Kyle

On the road full time with Son and 21 year old cat and 3 year old Manx.

Toyota Landcruiser 100 series V8.  Nextgen semi off-roader.  3 120 AH agm batteries, 1KW Solar



Senior Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 180
Date:

not sure if your Transit is a different layout to ours but we have the starter battery under the drivers seat and 2x 120aH AGM batteries under the passenger seat. We looked at 150aH batteries but they are too long. Hope that helps



__________________

BJC

"A year from now you'll wish you had started today."



Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 7642
Date:

What compressor fridge / freezer would replace a 180litre 3 way ? Yes I need to check actual dementions . What brand is everyone using ?? I know the two or three top brands . Has anyone had a good run with budget type .. ? I'll possibly go the $2500!-3000 fridge . Just asking how the sub $1000 have gone ??

__________________
Whats out there
msg


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 1785
Date:

In Transit,  Thanks for that. 

I am about to replace my batteries and will consider the 120ah as I have approx. 350 wts solar panels on roof. 

Real pain last winter with all the rain in QLD.  Only problem with compressor fridges.  If you don't have sun they don't work.   Otherwise, I think their efficiency is superior to gas.



__________________
Page 1 of 1  sorted by
 
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.

Tweet this page Post to Digg Post to Del.icio.us
Purchase Grey Nomad bumper stickers Read our daily column, the Nomad News The Grey Nomad's Guidebook