check out the new remote control Jockey Wheel SmartBar Topargee products Enginesaver Low Water Alarms
Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
Post Info TOPIC: AIR SUSPENSION


Newbie

Status: Offline
Posts: 4
Date:
AIR SUSPENSION


I have been looking at a well known of brand off road caravan. A load sharing air suspension option is available made by Top Gun Trailers on the Sunshine Coast. It is an expensive option. I have been told the suspension is second to none BUT the suspension is frequently supplied with all sorts of problems. Does anyone have one of these? What has been your experience?

 



__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 7642
Date:

Air bag suspension itself I'd fine.. It's the design, strength, axle location etc .. I have built the odd car Trailer carrier with bags so it can be lowered to drive car on.. Make sure frame is strong where it's attached.. Compared to leaf springs..
Same with bag assist in light trucks ..

__________________
Whats out there


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 1947
Date:

Darwin99 wrote:

I have been looking at a well known of brand off road caravan. A load sharing air suspension option is available made by Top Gun Trailers on the Sunshine Coast. It is an expensive option. I have been told the suspension is second to none BUT the suspension is frequently supplied with all sorts of problems. Does anyone have one of these? What has been your experience?


 Hi,

I do not have air bags so perhaps I should just shut up.confuse

I fail to see why you would put them on a vehicle which you do not ride in. More trouble, more expense, more to go wrong and in most cases badly engineered IMHO.

Use tried and proven leaf springs of a suitable spring rate and a bit of maintainance occasionally.hmm

Jaahn

 



__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 910
Date:

I have air bags, independent in a single axle type arrangement (if that makes sense). Worth twice what I paid for it. Side to side leveling is a breeze and front to back gets some help. Corrugations seem to disappear. Just remember that bags get harder as compression comes on so there is room for argument if towing around corners above 150KPH. I have Firestone brand bags and have done about 7,500 in the dirt. What sort of problems frequently come with the setup you are looking at?

Iza

__________________

Iza

Semi-permanent state of being Recreationally Outraged as a defence against boredom during lockdown.



Newbie

Status: Offline
Posts: 4
Date:

I have been told the suspension is great once the quality problems with the fabrication have been sorted out. Seems the arms vary in size causing various problems like camber and tracking of the tandem axles; chewing bushes;brake backing plate etc. and also air leaks. You would think air leaks would be easy to pick up but its left to the customer. One owner was having to stop every 20 minutes to top up the air pressure! Bit of an absence of quality checking in manufacture. I have spoken to two owners that just love the suspension but both had a lot of problems to sort out. One owner had a list of problems a page long.

__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 730
Date:

I am glad that someone has come up with this topic. I have been trying to get info on air suspension for a while now, but got nowhere. My problem is that I would like new poptop caravan which must fit into my shed. Doorway 2.3 m high, so to compensate for slight change of gradient on way in, I need a travel height of 2.25 m max. Then, I have to clear the driveway crossing into the street, so I need a good ground clearance. To me, adjustable air suspension seems the answer. Then you have the benefit of a much smoother ride for your van. My current van is a 1999 Jayco poptop which clears the doorway quite well, but scrapes its bum on the driveway crossing.

Now to the questions...
1 Alignment problems: Assuming independant suspension, I cannot see any more problems with air suspension over conventional springs. Assuming they are separate air supplies, if one bag leaks, you would obviously finish up with a leaning van, and due to possible camber change, maybe it may cause it to crab a little. What else can go wrong?

2 Air Leakage: I assume that the air bags will eventually leak air from somewhere. If they do, when the van was set up for camping, the stabilisers would finish up bearing a much higher load than possibly they were designed for. Can the stabilisers take the full weight of a varavan or are they merely stabilisers?

3 Bump stops: Do air suspensions have bump stops? I assume that they must, because without them there could be a lot of damage when the bags lose their air.

4 Automatic Restoration of Ride Height: To top up the air whilst travelling should not be a huge problem. My old Citroen DS21 had this facility. When a load was placed in the vehicle, front and rear sensors decided if more oil should be added to the appropriate end and suspension height was restored. If the vehicle was unloaded, it used to dump excess oil and the carwould sink back to its pre-set height. For a van air suspension, I imagine that a small compressed air tank and 12V compressor would be needed to maintain automatic ride height control. Changing the pre-set height would be relatively easy with a knob on the side or front of the van, connected to a valve. DO existing air systems have anything like this form of control?

5 Ability to kneel: My wife complains whenever we park facing downhill, because to level the van means that the step on the doorway is too high. If we could lower the to a park height, it would make for easier access and egress. Also, the ability to jack up the van to change a tyre would be enhanced with adjustable suspension. Do existing commercial air systems allow for the van to have adjustable heights for differing reasons?

6 Dynamic Stability: Because the air suspension is relatively soft, is there a tendency for the van to develop a swaying action? By this, I don't mean fishtailing, but rather a side to side rocking as the van moves along. I know that dampers (shock absorbers) should damp that sort of motion out, but has anyone experienced this?

7 Cost: Does anyone know how much the air system costs, compared to a standard spring setup? People have said to me it costs heaps more, but in the overall big picture of getting a new van built to specifications, is the extra cost that significant?


I'll put my hard hat on now so you can all throw brickbats at me, but any comments on the above would be welcom.

__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 910
Date:

I have air bag suspension from Vehicle Components. Alignment procedure is quick and easy and documented on their site. Onboard compressor with a small holding tank maintains set pressure. Control switches for each side let me put one side up or down at will. Never had the problem but busted bags just result in things sitting on the bump stops until repairs. I have let bags down to flat to get under trees and branches. I have also pumped them up to max to get through spoon drains without scrapping the rear.

I have twin shocks each side and reckon the van rocks less than one with conventional leaf springs. I paid a lot of attention to where the weight is in my van, tanks and batteries very close to the axle line, and have had no sway problems.

I know my system was at the costly end of the range.

Iza

__________________

Iza

Semi-permanent state of being Recreationally Outraged as a defence against boredom during lockdown.



Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 7642
Date:

Kits are quite are well priced . You need to fabricate brackets and add some strength to some areas depending on what model etc .. It's not the bags themselves that may cause issues . You can't blame bags for bad suspension, geometry . I buy my bags ex US . Exchange rate at present doesn't help ..

__________________
Whats out there


Senior Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 294
Date:

Izabarack wrote:

I have air bag suspension from Vehicle Components. Alignment procedure is quick and easy and documented on their site. Onboard compressor with a small holding tank maintains set pressure. Control switches for each side let me put one side up or down at will. Never had the problem but busted bags just result in things sitting on the bump stops until repairs. I have let bags down to flat to get under trees and branches. I have also pumped them up to max to get through spoon drains without scrapping the rear.

I have twin shocks each side and reckon the van rocks less than one with conventional leaf springs. I paid a lot of attention to where the weight is in my van, tanks and batteries very close to the axle line, and have had no sway problems.

I know my system was at the costly end of the range.

Iza


Fully endorse what Iza has written.

Would not have a caravan without air bags costly yes but worth it

Dhutime  



__________________

Keep your eyes open so you can see where you are heading



Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 2206
Date:

Izabarack wrote:

I have air bag suspension from Vehicle Components. Alignment procedure is quick and easy and documented on their site. Onboard compressor with a small holding tank maintains set pressure. Control switches for each side let me put one side up or down at will. Never had the problem but busted bags just result in things sitting on the bump stops until repairs. I have let bags down to flat to get under trees and branches. I have also pumped them up to max to get through spoon drains without scrapping the rear.

I have twin shocks each side and reckon the van rocks less than one with conventional leaf springs. I paid a lot of attention to where the weight is in my van, tanks and batteries very close to the axle line, and have had no sway problems.

I know my system was at the costly end of the range.

Iza


Sounds like a very good rig. I hope we meet somewhere/sometime I'd love to see it.

We have Firestones on rear of LC79 series Ute, they never loose pressure even at the low 5-7psi I run them, which I found amazing.



__________________

Why is it so? Professor Julius Sumner Miller, a profound influence on my life, who explained science to us on TV in the 60's.



Newbie

Status: Offline
Posts: 4
Date:

I noticed there is discussion of the Top Gun air suspension on the caravaners forum. Again reports of quality issues. Bushtracker have now ceased using this brand of air suspension.

__________________
Page 1 of 1  sorted by
 
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.

Tweet this page Post to Digg Post to Del.icio.us
Purchase Grey Nomad bumper stickers Read our daily column, the Nomad News The Grey Nomad's Guidebook