I have read the article a number of times now and I am nonplussed.
It appears that the NRMA is aware of a regulation/law that caravan/trailer number plates must be mounted no higher than 1.3metres above the ground.
And obviously a police officer was aware of it as well and applied the letter of this law in issuing a fine.
Unfortunately, the article does not provide a link, or other identification, of such a law/regulation.
I certainly am not challenging that somewhere such a regulation/law must exist but I have spent a little bit of time through my old friend Mr Google trying to locate such a document. I have been completely unsuccessful.
These are some of the fruits of those searches. There are regulations within but none mention 1.3metres above ground - only 20 metres of visibility. All seem to show the same diagram to determine the application of the "20 metre" rule -
if you get an infringement notice like that(or any infringement notice for that matter) ask the officer to quote the regulation number that refers to the offence
Provision must be made for mounting of a 372 mm x 136 mm registration plate to the rear of every trailer so that no part of the plate is more than 1300 mm above the ground
I also just measured my Jayco Freedom. The height actually came to 1300mm (or 1.3m) at the CENTER of the number plate.
So it would appear that technically I am at risk of booking according to the information provided by Hylda and son - ie; no part of the plate is to be MORE THAN 1300MM ABOVE GROUND!
As I have been towing the van for two years now through NSW, QLD and VIC without being pulled over I think that I'll take my chances. Perhaps the 1300mm being halfway up the plate will mean that I'll only get half the fine?
yet another example of wildly different laws in Each State so that the 1000's of otherwise useless public servants can maintain their over paid jobs by each writing their own ideas.
Im an ex-Kiwi (yeah - had the lobotomy and now wear thongs on my feet than round my butt and drink XXXX rather than Steinlager - hard to say, I guess) and all the laws over there are universal. Even council (don't have shires) by-laws are uniform from top to bottom - they can only choose to apply them or not, but not write up the weird and wonderful.
We're based in WA and the huge number of trucks and other motor vehicles running round with no number plates at all, or badly damaged, or so faded out or dity as to be unreadable....if a WA cop pulled me up for this - I'd just laugh at him and tell him to get a life. If he persists - then - seeya in Court!!!!
__________________
Cheers Bruce
The amazing things you see when nomading Australia
Provision must be made for mounting of a 372 mm x 136 mm registration plate to the rear of every trailer so that no part of the plate is more than 1300 mm above the ground.
So I ask the question, if your caravan is non compliant to ADR 61-02 section 9 and the van is still under warranty then the following section should apply;
6. Conditions Relating to Non-Complying Road Trailers
If a road trailer does not comply with the requirements of the Motor Vehicle Standards Act 1989 (the Act) or this bulletin, the manufacturer or importer is required to:
Conduct a safety investigation into the issues surrounding the non-compliance. This investigation shall report on the cause of the non-compliance, the number of road vehicles affected and any other relevant facts or circumstances. This report should then be forwarded to the Administrator of Vehicle Standards within 14 days.
If an issue of non-compliance is detected the manufacturer or importer is to cease supplying the affected vehicles to the market immediately and to notify owners that the vehicle does not comply and should be withdrawn from service until action can be undertaken to correct the non-compliance.
The manufacturer must determine if the non compliance is a safety related issue, in which case a voluntary or mandatory recall is to occur in accordance with the Procedures for the Rectification of Safety Related Defects in Vehicles and Related Products (the Recall Code). In instances where the non compliance is deemed not to be a safety related matter, a manufacturer or importer may utilise a field service campaign to resolve the non-compliance.
So, return your caravan to a selling dealer and ask them to fix the number plate location and any electrical work at no cost.
It would be interesting to check with the state DFT and find out who is responsible for the work if out of warranty.......I would suggest the seller is responsible for all cost, he has a duty of care for the van to be legal on the road.
I would be asking for a refund for the cost of the fine from the seller, you won't get the demerit points back.
I understand that this is a law but as laws go it is extremely minor (except for $415/3D Points). I also understand that the Police are charged with up holding the law but for the sake of common sense what is wrong with pulling the criminal over and letting them know what the standards are so they rectify it.
I don't believe any Police commissioner would agree that this is such a high priced crime that a simple warning (education) could not have rectified but to fine some one borders on abuse of office.
Wouldn't go as far as to call him a jerk, He's just another person in uniform that has studied the books for easy infractions to get his booking count up to satisfy his superiors. I would look at fighting it in court as far as the points are concerned, because in spite of my above statement, it is over the top., it's not unsafe, and it's not endangering anyone.
If he had more get up, he would challenge and take it to the local court magistrate. He / She would flip it under section 10 of the local traffic act.
I did simlar here in Sydney. My son was booked for putting two tyres over double yellow lines by 300mm,(Filmed by Highway patro,l in cars camara,) in narrow street. to pass a stationery truck.
We returned to the same spot on a Saturday morning before this went any further.
We videoed and took photo's of 114 cars, trucks, taxis, both government vehicles, council garbage trucks as well, in exactly the same spot over a two hour period.
Took them to the area police station. ( Fine was to stay,) We wrote to the dept recovery office.(Fine is to Stay).
My son, Wife And I attended the local court.
The male Magistrate looked at six photo's only. and asked the prosercuting sargent would the NSW police dept be prepaired to follow up in their own time, to issue the 114 offenders with the same infringement notice, If this young man makes a formal complaint to the police.
The Prosercuting sargent did not challenge. And it was throwen out.
My son had held his licence only for six years, without a infringement / penilties. The police cited, leniency only applied to those who had ten years without infringement. The Magistrate told our son to keep up his good driving record, and be a good example to other young drivers.
I agree in education.......but as they say the law is the law . I think the height requirements for the number plate is for the speed/safety cameras etc.
Yesterday, someone was saying that your mudflaps must be no higher than the centre of your hubs, I know that the book states the mudflap must not be lower than 230mm from the ground.
I have also heard that the breakaway cable cannot be attached to the D shackle holding the chain, it cable must be attached separately to the tow bar, the problem is that many tow bars the D shackle hole will not accept 2 D shackles (different sizes of course).
Rockylizard note that they are now pinging anyone carrying fuel on rear carriers - this is apparently a problem in rear end crashes as pressurised fuel sprays and ignites.
__________________
Possum; AKA:- Ali El-Aziz Mohamed Gundawiathan
Sent from my imperial66 typewriter using carrier pigeon, message sticks and smoke signals.
Green 20 ltr Jerry is diesel - rarely filled. Considered safe even if filled.
Small red 10ltr Jerry usually only has 4 to 5 ltrs of ULP - if I am going 'bush' and might need chainsaw. I therefore fill it at the town immediately before heading to the 'bush camp'. It is rarely filled and I rarely use chainsaw as I find my bow saw and axe work best.
I have been advised by 'authorities' that this amount in small Jerry, carried well inside the steel carrier, is not an unsafe practice.
Cheers - John
__________________
2006 Discovery 3 TDV6 SE Auto - 2008 23ft Golden Eagle Hunter Some people feel the rain - the others just get wet - Bob Dylan
yet another example of wildly different laws in Each State so that the 1000's of otherwise useless public servants can maintain their over paid jobs by each writing their own ideas.
I understand the reason for your comment however the following maybe of interest to you.
Break away cable anchor point
NSW VSI9 - Revision 4 Nov 2003
Comment only:
This anchor point must be independent of the tow hitch. It is recommended that it either be attached to the main body of the tow bar assembly or to the chassis of the tow vehicle.
It must not be attached to the Tow Bar Tongue, safety chain or the safety chain attachment point.
From the RMS (RTA)
The break Away cable must be attached:
On a mounting point strong enough to pull the cable out of the switch without failure of that mounting point.
A mounting point not located on a 'tongue' which can be removed.
In a position that does not allow the cable to catch on debris and/or be cut or frayed by fouling on other (vehicle or trailer) components or the ground (road)
oh....all these rules are just so much rubbish !!!!!!
Surely road traffic laws are about safety............when it comes to towing, must of them are just b.s. And many say "should" - not "will", so different road traffic cops apply them differently - some use common sense and others are just on power trips (and I was a cop for 13 years - fortunately not a road one - and we say many who couldn't be a real cop drive a V8 instead and pick up people for stupid and poorly written laws which cause all police officers to be hated as a result
__________________
Cheers Bruce
The amazing things you see when nomading Australia
Thanks for that Migra, obviously haven't seen that NSW document as I'm in SA. Had remembered seeing this discussion previously, and it was stated there what I wrote as there had been a situation where the whole tow bar came off the tow vehicle!!. Always happy to be corrected.
It is interesting, in the current Caravan & motorhome magazine (No 217), pages 24, 25 and 30 show an image of a Crusader caravan which appears the number plate is higher than 1300mm and on page 43 a Honda ad shows an image of a caravan with its number plate being higher than 1300mm, if so, these caravans are illegal and how could they be registered and who registered the caravans.
i have written to the editor of the above magazine bringing their attention to this issue and have asked them to contact the caravan industry for comment and what is the caravan industry going to do to correct the situation, A, B or C.
6. Conditions Relating to Non-Complying Road Trailers
If a road trailer does not comply with the requirements of the Motor Vehicle Standards Act 1989 (the Act) or this bulletin, the manufacturer or importer is required to:
Conduct a safety investigation into the issues surrounding the non-compliance. This investigation shall report on the cause of the non-compliance, the number of road vehicles affected and any other relevant facts or circumstances. This report should then be forwarded to the Administrator of Vehicle Standards within 14 days.
If an issue of non-compliance is detected the manufacturer or importer is to cease supplying the affected vehicles to the market immediately and to notify owners that the vehicle does not comply and should be withdrawn from service until action can be undertaken to correct the non-compliance.
The manufacturer must determine if the non compliance is a safety related issue, in which case a voluntary or mandatory recall is to occur in accordance with the Procedures for the Rectification of Safety Related Defects in Vehicles and Related Products (the Recall Code). In instances where the non compliance is deemed not to be a safety related matter, a manufacturer or importer may utilise a field service campaign to resolve the non-compliance.
I have requested a reply so I await their comment !!!!!!
I await with interest.
P.S. With the RMS in NSW now taking the caravan inspection from normal motor vehicle inspectors and moving it to heavy vehicle motor inspection stations some of the issues will be corrected. The problem is the costs to rectify the problem is always on the consumer NOT the manufacturer or selling dealer.
yet another example of wildly different laws in Each State so that the 1000's of otherwise useless public servants can maintain their over paid jobs by each writing their own ideas.
No truer words ever spoken/
Bunkum, The first issue of VSB-1 was issued in June 1999. It has been accepted by all states. I believe the number plate dimension has been in every revision, we are up to revision 5. I remember reading through the motor traffic NSW regulations in the 70s and there were dimensions for the placement of lights and number plates similar to the ones in VSB-1. The states have been talking together about uniform traffic laws and regulations. The introduction of compliance plates in 1989 is one of these uniform regulations. Many more have followed.
Before you start maligning politicians and public servants get your facts straight. Comments like those just make you look stupid idiots and shows we should not take notice to anything you post.
__________________
PeterD Nissan Navara D23 diesel auto, Spaceland pop-top Retired radio and electronics technician. NSW Central Coast.
Now the Queensland rule don't say anything about how high off the ground
That is just an advisory notice applying to "replacing or changing a number plate." It is not legislation, just advice expounding some sections of legislation.
Queensland has adopted VSB-1. You will find the rules in it that apply to Qld. In turn VSB-1 is a collection of pieces of legislation from superior sources, in this case Vehicle Standard (Australian Design Rule 61/02 - Vehicle Marking) 2005 Section 9, REGISTRATION PLATES AND LABEL HOLDERS.
.
-- Edited by PeterD on Monday 25th of May 2015 01:57:20 PM
__________________
PeterD Nissan Navara D23 diesel auto, Spaceland pop-top Retired radio and electronics technician. NSW Central Coast.