check out the new remote control Jockey Wheel SmartBar Topargee products Enginesaver Low Water Alarms
Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
Post Info TOPIC: To take a generator or not ???


Newbie

Status: Offline
Posts: 3
Date:
To take a generator or not ???


Hi everyone, I am a new member and this is my first post and I would appreciate some advice on the following. We are hitting the road in May to commence our big lap and I am struggling as to whether or not to take a generator with us. We need to be mindful of our weights. I have 2 genies a 2 kva and a 2.6. My conundrum is we have ample solar with 250 on the roof and another 120 portable. In the past we have really only used the genie to run the microwave or my wife's hairdryer etc absolutely nothing essential, our solar set up does pretty much everything we need. The only reason I can see to take a genie is if we are parked up in a shady spot for a while but then I have the portable solar to top things up. So is it worth carting all that extra weight plus fuel to run it if I may never need it. Be very interested to hear your thoughts especially those who have taken a genie and how often it was used. cheers folks safe travels mwez



__________________
Mark Wehse


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 7582
Date:

I haven't used a microwave for over a decade at home. Just got out of the habit & there are many work arounds in a saucepan. That means you can save weight & get rid of the microwave as well. Maybe pack the hair dryer for the odd occasion when you are in a caravan park.



__________________

Procrastination, mankind's greatest labour saving device!

50L custom fuel rack 6x20W 100/20mppt 4x26Ah gel 28L super insulated fridge TPMS 3 ARB compressors heatsink fan cooled 4L tank aftercooler Air/water OCD cleaning 4 stage car acoustic insulation.



Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 1021
Date:

We have never felt the need to have a generator. Don't have a microwave,Air Con, Water Heater.  We stay off grid whenever we can and are on trips  some times of 4-5 months some years. Off  again to the Kimberly this year for a few months, Broome bird Obs. Charnley and Mornington  Wildlife conservancies.  We have enough Solar Power and Battery power for all our needs in an Avan Cruisliner.

 



__________________

Mike & Ellie



Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 1989
Date:

G'day mwez. Welcome to the forum. Advice from one who carries a generator. While not on the road full time I take ours. 2kva Honda. Not used often BUT when needed was needed. Solar panels are great and we have stayed of grid for 5 weeks only needing to use the genni about 3 or 4 times. Sometimes to help others. If you think you need it to power a microwave or hair dryer probably (with respect) you may need to change your way of cooking and introduce your wife to a towel to dry her hair. May I ask about your fridge, is it 12/240 or 3 way. Lots of people dont like gas fridges but I love ours. Is your car petrol or diesel?  Petrol means you can use the same fuel. Bottom line is, this is a decision only you can make but I would suggest you take one. I know you will get a lot of differing opinions on this,

Cheers

 



__________________

Jack Cherie and the memory of the four legged kids.



Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 4375
Date:

And from someone who has spent about 6 months on the road each year for the past 15 years, almost only off grid.
We don't have a generator, nor can we plug in to 240V at all.
We have lots of solar and if the sun does not shine there is an alternator under the bonnet that can charge our batteries up very easily.
Spend the money you were going to spend on the generator (plus its smelly, dangerous fuel) on extra solar panels instead and you will be sweet.
Cheers,
Peter

__________________

OKA196, 4x4 'C' Class, DIY, self contained motorhome. 960W of solar, 400Ah of AGMs, 310L water, 280L fuel. https://www.oka4wd.com/forum/members-vehicles-public/569-oka196-xt-motorhome
 

 



Senior Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 148
Date:

I suspect you've already answered your own question. And I suspect your answer is no. 



__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 1378
Date:

There weighty noisy thinks that stink of fuel,not needed today with modern 12volt systems ,if you want to cart one around to power a hair dryer that makes a lot of sense biggrin ..



__________________


Veteran Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 97
Date:

We take our generator , to charge batteries when poor solar ( like when under nice shady trees for a few days - like on a river bank) .... I well remember when camped up for a few weeks & overcast for 7 days , solar insufficient so ran generator - other solar only vans asked if they could connect

__________________
HAPPINESS is a journey, not a destination. So work like you don't need the money, Sing like no-one is listening, Love like you've never been hurt & Dance like no one's watching


Newbie

Status: Offline
Posts: 3
Date:

Thanks for that vehicle is a 3ltr TD prado also van is fitted with a diesel heater so the only thing I would need to carry fuel for is the genie. I have advised he wife towel ONLY lolllblankstare 



__________________
Mark Wehse


Newbie

Status: Offline
Posts: 3
Date:

Thanks everyone for your replies and suggestions been great to get some different points of view. cheers & safe travels.

__________________
Mark Wehse


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 4248
Date:

Strop n i are on the road full time. Most of the time we do not need it. But when you need it, you need it. Eg. 1. raining for one week and shock, horror, no tv, internet or hot water. 2. Its that hot you are sweltering. 3. You get vomiting n diarhoea, r running a temp., feel like crap and its very hot n humid n are in the middle of nowhere but cannot drive any further. No fun vomiting by torch light and Cleaning up vomit by torch light because  you have used all the solar power.  Also cannot heat water for shower. Usually find when you do not take something, thats the item you will need most.  If it were me, i would take the big genie, for just in case. Enjoy your travels. Rocket n strop.

 



-- Edited by the rocket on Friday 15th of March 2019 11:04:14 AM

__________________


Chief one feather

Status: Offline
Posts: 17428
Date:

Oh no, someone mentioned a Generator! crysmile

 

Welcome to the gang mwez, enjoy here an out in the playground.

I am on the road full time, no home base anymore, so everything needed is with me.. I have heaps of Solar up on the roof and portable 120w fold up Solar sheet and two batteries on/in my aluminium teepee. I carry a Honda 20i Generator in the back of the Collie all the times. I have it for when off the grid and only for aircon if needed. I feel the heat quickly and badly. I have a Truma Gas Heater fitted for colder weather as I also feel the cold quickly and badly. 

The Generator doesn't get much use but more than happy to have on board for if needed. 

 

My comment up the top could be worse I spose as it could be someone carrying a Generator in a Whizzbang.........Who said that! Not me, no way disbeliefnobiggrin

 



__________________

Live Life On Your Terms

DOUG  Chief One Feather  (Losing feathers with age)

TUG.......2014 Holden LT Colorado Twin Cab Ute with Canopy

DEN....... 2014 "Chief" Arrow CV  (with some changes)

 



Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 4248
Date:

Dougwe wrote:

Oh no, someone mentioned a Generator! crysmile

 

Welcome to the gang mwez, enjoy here an out in the playground.

I am on the road full time, no home base anymore, so everything needed is with me.. I have heaps of Solar up on the roof and portable 120w fold up Solar sheet and two batteries on/in my aluminium teepee. I carry a Honda 20i Generator in the back of the Collie all the times. I have it for when off the grid and only for aircon if needed. I feel the heat quickly and badly. I have a Truma Gas Heater fitted for colder weather as I also feel the cold quickly and badly. 

The Generator doesn't get much use but more than happy to have on board for if needed. 

 

My comment up the top could be worse I spose as it could be someone carrying a Generator in a Whizzbang.........Who said that! Not me, no way disbeliefnobiggrin

 


 Totally agree. Hope you are recovering ok. heard the twins came down from byron to help you. You luckyman. Sorry, off topic. Back to original post.



__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 1948
Date:

Hi Mark smile

Here is another point of view. Your Prado has a good alternator which can be used to charge your van battery. So when travelling it can fully charge it normally and the batteries are full when you arrive. Then you can use the solar for your power. If the solar is poor and your batteries get down, you can always run the motor to charge up the batteries. You are not stuck with flat house batteries as has been implied and cannot charge them. 

Indeed if you still want to use a microwave or a hair drier for a short time you could run the motor to keep the batteries charged while you do that. Easier than lugging a generator and less weight for sure.biggrin 

The thing is to setup your rig correctly to enable the charging from the Prado alternator to work well as you want it to. Depending on the model it will probably need a DC to DC charger and a good sized cable and connector. Buy a high amp charger that will recharge in a shorter time. A 20Amp unit will do charging driving but not much help other times. 

Jaahn



-- Edited by Jaahn on Friday 15th of March 2019 12:04:12 PM

__________________
LLD


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 600
Date:

We have the Yamaha version of the Honda 20i. Carried in on our 10 week, 10,000km trip around the west. Never used it. We never stayed any longer than a few days without power. However I am glad we took it as we have needed it where we have stayed more than about 3 nights without moving on. The worst that can happen (and we did it on one trip) is to run the ute to top-up the van battery. We tend to run out of battery power in the ute powering the 12v fridge to keep the beer cold on very hot days when we are camped.

Between a gas powered van fridge and the butane cookers you can travel anywhere. Our 2 pair of travelling companions had generators but also used their butane stoves rather than getting out the generator.

The most important thing is drinking water. We've filled our van tank with dubious water. Even filled with good water that tastes horrible. So taking your own drinking water is a must whether it be purchased bottled or you fill containers up in places where water is clean and tastes OK. We save and refill our water bottles when we can rather than purchase more.

__________________
KFT


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 2437
Date:

Just wondering if I should get some popcorn in for this discussion?

We have a honda genny and have used it many times over the last 8 years. I figure it was better to have it and not need it than to need it and not have it. It is only 20kg and 5 l of fuel is another 5 approx. We also carry a 100l bladder full of our rainwater for drinking and that is only the weight of another passenger in the vehicle.

We have used it to charge batteries, run the AC, run the microwave(couple of times only and usually for a heat pack), so it has been very handy indeed.

Do what you think is best for you and take no notice of the naysayers.

Frank.

__________________

Avagreatday.

Kathy and Frank currently at Home near Quirindi NSW



Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 2814
Date:

mwez wrote:

Hi everyone, I am a new member and this is my first post and I would appreciate some advice on the following. We are hitting the road in May to commence our big lap and I am struggling as to whether or not to take a generator with us. We need to be mindful of our weights. I have 2 genies a 2 kva and a 2.6. My conundrum is we have ample solar with 250 on the roof and another 120 portable. In the past we have really only used the genie to run the microwave or my hair dryer etc absolutely nothing essential, our solar set up does pretty much everything we need. The only reason I can see to take a genie is if we are parked up in a shady spot for a while but then I have the portable solar to top things up. So is it worth carting all that extra weight plus fuel to run it if I may never need it. Be very interested to hear your thoughts especially those who have taken a genie and how often it was used. cheers folks safe travels mwez


 Hi mwez,

In your own words, if you can do without a hair dryer and microwave leave it home otherwise you'll be like the majority here who have taken it and not used it.

I'm thinking if start in May and head North and follow the temperate weather around Aust, you probably won't need it.

Cheers Bob



__________________

Make it Snappy......Bob

 



Senior Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 386
Date:

I guess you need to figure, what happens if the panels don't keep up and you can't use your batteries .

For me I'd need to pile the van food into the Tug and not have as many cold drinks ready to go. 

My lights wouldn't work but i have torches and head lamps. 

Cooking is on gas. 

So for me no biggie. 


What will you need to go without?

Will that bother you too much to do without for a few days ?

If the second answer is no, then don't take one.
If it's a yes, then take one

Simples

 

that's how it works in my head anyway biggrin 

Plus making a decision on such things is much easier when it's someone else taking the risks. evileye

cheers Brett 



__________________


Veteran Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 97
Date:

Jaahn wrote:

Hi Mark smile

Here is another point of view. Your Prado has a good alternator which can be used to charge your van battery. So when travelling it can fully charge it normally and the batteries are full when you arrive. Then you can use the solar for your power. If the solar is poor and your batteries get down, you can always run the motor to charge up the batteries. You are not stuck with flat house batteries as has been implied and cannot charge them. 

Indeed if you still want to use a microwave or a hair drier for a short time you could run the motor to keep the batteries charged while you do that. Easier than lugging a generator and less weight for sure.biggrin 

The thing is to setup your rig correctly to enable the charging from the Prado alternator to work well as you want it to. Depending on the model it will probably need a DC to DC charger and a good sized cable and connector. Buy a high amp charger that will recharge in a shorter time. A 20Amp unit will do charging driving but not much help other times. 

Jaahn


Seems a waste of fuel to run a large motor for several hours just to charge batteries , esp considering deep cycle batteries can be slow to accept charge ... plus there is the issue with catalytic coverters on new vehicles - not recommended to idle for long periods - for several reasons


-- Edited by Jaahn on Friday 15th of March 2019 12:04:12 PM


 



__________________
HAPPINESS is a journey, not a destination. So work like you don't need the money, Sing like no-one is listening, Love like you've never been hurt & Dance like no one's watching


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 1378
Date:

Most people would not be carting generators around these days ,we and the people we travel with have never had a need for them,and we freecamp most of the time,I have no problem with people carting the things around, in there head there there for emergencies , if you dont hnow how to set your rig up to do without them there a security blanket I suppose ,if you want to sit out in the Bush in pouring rain  I guess they might make sense biggrin



__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 544
Date:

Generators are great cause when for an example if you are free camping on 4 acres and there is no one else there some one decides to park at your front door just put it on and they soon move on they are also great for air con 



__________________

John

2017 dmax lovells upgrade full CSM trade  aluminium canopy,3.5 m quintrex tinny and rear boat loader mangrove jack aluminium trailer

JB scorpion sting 206



Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 1835
Date:

My 2 bobs worth..

Yes we carry A HONDA I.20 in a box on the rear of the rig.

It is used mainly when we have a lack of solar power during rainy days on end.

Also we are bush campers and on goes the Genie on wash days and whne the Dee wants to use the dryer and micro wave. Also use it for the A/Con so yes we have a need for the Genie,

But!!!!  I guess not everyone has the same needs and desires.  

Happy Days

Jay&Dee



__________________
Page 1 of 1  sorted by
 
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.

Tweet this page Post to Digg Post to Del.icio.us
Purchase Grey Nomad bumper stickers Read our daily column, the Nomad News The Grey Nomad's Guidebook