check out the new remote control Jockey Wheel SmartBar Topargee products Enginesaver Low Water Alarms
Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
Post Info TOPIC: roof mounted aircon vs domestic split system


Veteran Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 58
Date:
roof mounted aircon vs domestic split system


L read on the internet sites that alot of vanners are changing from roof mounted to reverse split system . Love to have the nomads thoughts . Ty

__________________

IF IT GOING TO BE, ITS UP TO ME



Senior Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 419
Date:

A quality brand roof mounted aircon will do a good job.It is a neat and tidy installation taking up minimal space.A split system on the other hand,while being cheaper and more efficient is heavier and has mounting deficiencies in terms of placement of components.I think it just depends upon your needs and preferences.

__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 1164
Date:

would not have another roof top model at any price. When we looked for another van it was with a split system installation in mind - that is, a layout that lends itself to that installation if and when the roof top model died and sure enough, 12 mths after we changed vans we needed to put our pre-conceived plan into action. All up cost was $1600 and cools the van noiselessly. Ran in 24/7 in Darwin and it was wonderful.

Our Dometic roof model was noisy and inefficient. In our previous van we had an 'ibis' which was equally as noisy and after spending over $600 to fix it the problem (not cooling E4 error) was still there.

 We live in our van full time and not prepared to put up with sub-standard appliances.



-- Edited by villatranquilla on Tuesday 2nd of February 2016 04:04:06 PM

__________________

Jenny and Barry

2009 Roma Elegance / 2013 Colorado. Permanent travellers 2011-2015 now just travel for 4-6 mths 



Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 1081
Date:

Our van came standard with a domestic split system and after looking at a heap of other vans most with roof mounted systems I'm glad about that. We have a Kelvinator but we have friends with a Samsung and they are just as happy with what they have, Its cheaper to buy, it uses less electricity, its easier to get it repaired and/or serviced, its quieter to operate both inside and out and it doesn't increase the height of the van. No comparison.

I've often wondered why more van manufacturers don't do the same.

Regards

Dave

__________________

Mr & Ms D - On the road at last

Mazda BT50 towing a 22'6" Aussie Humpback

See you on the road



Senior Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 415
Date:

For a starter there is no comparison, it's like chalk and cheese.

We have had every rooftop rattler going in our previous caravans, now have a Fujitsu Inverter split, runs easily from a 1kva yamaha genny, try that with an Ibis !

Works quietly and efficiently and no crash bang like the old thumper kicks in with the dinosaur rooftops.

I would never consider another piece of rooftop rubbish ever ! from any manufacturer. Oh and ours now is nearly 4 years old, full time use sometimes 24/7 for weeks on end, try that with a rattler.

I'd rather have no AC than the old noisy technology foisted on us by some idiot caravan manufacturers

__________________
brian


Veteran Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 58
Date:

Ty so far for all your responses, look like a split domestic system will be the way to go . D and D, Banjo where is your outdoor unit mounted and how big are the units your both got . I guessing l am concerned about vibrations, loose connections over time and gas escaping out . Ty

__________________

IF IT GOING TO BE, ITS UP TO ME



Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 865
Date:

Her eis another vote for a split system, had a Fujitsu inverter system installed when the van was built, just brilliant, silent, and runs on very little power (important if you are running on inverter).



__________________

 

Discovery 4, 

Retreat Brampton

 



Veteran Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 58
Date:

Plento, how many kw is your unit and where the outdoor unit situated ?

__________________

IF IT GOING TO BE, ITS UP TO ME



Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 1081
Date:

adventure before dementia wrote:

Ty so far for all your responses, look like a split domestic system will be the way to go . D and D, Banjo where is your outdoor unit mounted and how big are the units your both got . I guessing l am concerned about vibrations, loose connections over time and gas escaping out . Ty


 The inverter unit is located at the rear of the van (see pic) which was possible because it was always going to be there so the van was constructed with that in mind. The header unit is located above the bed at the front of the van. I've seen the inverter's mounted on the rear bumber although I'd think twice about that because of the weight and I'd make sure it didn't affect the van's balance. The header can really go anywhere provided you can get the pipework to and from it.

 

Capacity is: Cool - input 0.65 kW, Output 2.65 kW; Heat - Input 0.75 kW, Output 2.90 kW., That's what it says on the sticker and I have no idea what that means. If I was getting it done again I'd probably go for a slightly larger capacity.

 

Regards

 

Dave



-- Edited by D and D on Wednesday 3rd of February 2016 06:04:07 PM

Attachments
__________________

Mr & Ms D - On the road at last

Mazda BT50 towing a 22'6" Aussie Humpback

See you on the road



Senior Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 415
Date:

My outside unit is on the rear bumper, my 5'er was designed to have it fitted there, the inside unit is above the rear kitchen window and cools our 30' unit easily.

So long as good installation practices are observed, eg no loose flapping pipes, the units are probably more reliable than a rooftop jobbie. I have heard of heaps of rooftop failures but only one split and that was a loose pipe that fractured.

That happens regularly on rooftop units.

__________________
brian


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 865
Date:

Our unit is a 1.5kw cooling, and from memory 1kw heating, the outside unit is on the back bumper, and the head unit is above the mirror in the ensuite, it blows straight up the middle of the van, and cools it quickly and quietly.

Our van was built to be totally independent, 1,200watts of solar, a big lithium battery, feeding a 3,000w inverter.

It was important to us that our air con was efficient, and that it was not on the roof, as we needed the space for the solar. We can run the air con for many hours after the sun goes down, to date we have run it for 5 hours, and still had loads of battery in the morning.

If we were building again there are a few things we would change, but we would seek out exactly the same air con unit again. 

Good luck with your decision.



__________________

 

Discovery 4, 

Retreat Brampton

 



Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 1880
Date:

Never liked the idea of roof mounted anything if it's going to leak it will start at any roof penetration It's like building a flat roof house the sealing lasts a year or two then the trouble starts . Like D D location and mounting ,very neat

__________________

Pets are welcome but children must be leashed at all times



Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 746
Date:

Hey plendo how's it goin . M8 how much did they flog you for a casket I just looked em up and 5 ish thousand . Is that rite 

 

dibs



__________________

gdyble

DONT DIE WONDERING ONE LIFE ONE CHANCE JUST DO IT 

Page 1 of 1  sorted by
 
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.

Tweet this page Post to Digg Post to Del.icio.us
Purchase Grey Nomad bumper stickers Read our daily column, the Nomad News The Grey Nomad's Guidebook