check out the new remote control Jockey Wheel SmartBar Topargee products Red Earth Festival Park Booker
Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
Post Info TOPIC: pop top campers vs hard top campers


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 3332
Date:
pop top campers vs hard top campers


you all know I've been doing my research and I was just wondering

for those with the pop top campers ,ie hi ace, 

how hard are they to bring the tops down when you want to?

I had a look at one today and it was bloody hard for me to pull down..

I think for me id rather a hi top, i know you'ld probably get more wind lag 

etc but  i cant think of doing that every time you stop over night... 

and i figure a hi top would be more insulated ?? confuse



__________________

The Drewsterz my band site

Milo Online  my personal site

Love what you do  Do what you Love!!   my motto in life !

 



Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 8735
Date:

I can still get mine up and down OK so far milo, but I'm going to go to the Gold Coast when I can afford to and get an RV airlifter unit installed .  Just have to press a button then, to put it up or down.  I find getting it up harder than getting it down.  I have a Solar Panel on top. 

http://www.rvairlifters.com.au/

Used to cost around $1,000.00 to convert.  Less if you do it yourself.  Might be a bit dearer these days.

Cheers,

Sheba.



__________________
An it harm none, do what you will.
Duh


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 3240
Date:

Milo,

My Hi Ace is easy to push up (I use my head to start it, some ladies I understand use a small stool) but hard to pull down. 

I was told by the people that do the conversion that they can adjust it to make it easier to pull down, but then it will be harder to push up and once adjusted I could not be reversed.

The missus came up with a brilliant idea of using a light rope in a skipping rope loop with a caribeena hook at each end.  The rope hooks are hooked onto the pull down handles, one end on each handle, and the looped rope stops short of the floor by about 8 inches.  To keep the rope apart at the bottom, I put a piece of clear plastic tubing on the rope at the bottom.

Then a simple matter of holding the pull down handles (with rope clipped on) and stepping onto the raised rope at the same time with one foot as you pull down on the handles, this gives the roof a start and then simply continue to pull the roof down by the handles.  When the roof is down remove the clip on hooks.   Works for me.

The high roofs do make life easier, and there is not a lot of difference in fuel usage (I tested my pop top against a high roof over 500 kms, both refuelling a the same time) in fact it was almost the same.   The high roof will give you a bit more buffeting in high side winds but not a great deal more.    Remember though that a high roof will generally not fit under a carport or any driver throughs (eg; McDonalds, underground carparks (some) or other type drive throughs, so you need to keep an eye on the boom heights.

 



__________________

Vic  - Mitsubishi Outlander and rear end tent....

 

 

 



 



Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 4001
Date:

Would a pop Top be colder in winter than a full height , Then would a Pop Top be cooler in summer , Storage seems to big then in favor of both Pop Top Van and Caravan

__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 8735
Date:

Don't know about being colder in Winter, but in Summer, you have 4 zippered windows,  that let a lot of breeze through to cool the 'van down, and they work beautifully.  You don't have that with a Hightop I think.

As for storage, I made the bed a 3/4, and bought storage drawer units from the Warehouse.

Campervan.jpg

 

 

Cheers,

Sheba.



-- Edited by Sheba on Monday 1st of October 2012 06:56:57 PM

Attachments
__________________
An it harm none, do what you will.
Duh


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 3240
Date:

brickies wrote:

Would a pop Top be colder in winter than a full height , Then would a Pop Top be cooler in summer , Storage seems to big then in favor of both Pop Top Van and Caravan


 I think full height in caravans would be better if you have aircon (cooling or heating) as you lose a bit through the canvas/vinyl on pop tops.

For free camping though in summer the pop top probably comes out on top if not running an A/C via a generator, but would be colder on a cool or windy night.

As far as caravans go, be aware that the fibreglass composite cladding ones are better than aluminium cladding for being cool or warm as the material is a better insulation against hot/cold etc.

At least this has been my experience with too caravans and one hard wall camper trailer I have had.  

 



__________________

Vic  - Mitsubishi Outlander and rear end tent....

 

 

 



 



Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 3332
Date:

i like the air lifters, if only you could use them in reverse to pull the top down..
seems to be more poptops than high tops for sale

__________________

The Drewsterz my band site

Milo Online  my personal site

Love what you do  Do what you Love!!   my motto in life !

 



Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 1619
Date:

Milo I think alot of the high tops are ex hire, often have largish klms on clock but I have seen 2008 vans reasonably priced because of the mileage.



__________________

Janette



Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 3332
Date:

thats the trouble i have seen the last year or so while researching, the amount of high k's and still high prices.. etc



__________________

The Drewsterz my band site

Milo Online  my personal site

Love what you do  Do what you Love!!   my motto in life !

 



The Master

Status: Offline
Posts: 12473
Date:

If I had my time again I would go for a hi top instead of a pop top. Would be one less thing to worry about.

__________________




Happy Wanderer    

Don't worry, Be Happy! 

Live! Like someone left the gate open

 

 

 



Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 3332
Date:

that's what im a little worried about HW..

__________________

The Drewsterz my band site

Milo Online  my personal site

Love what you do  Do what you Love!!   my motto in life !

 



Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 1619
Date:

I have seen later model Hiace Hitops for $29000 but 150,000ks ex hire.



__________________

Janette



Senior Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 126
Date:

I had a hi-top (Ford Econovan) back in NZ earlier this year and really liked being able to just jump in the back and get on with it without fiddling about. Driving was fine, pretty much like a standard van, even with the odd winds. Having said that, when one stops and unpacks for the night I imagine popping the roof takes just a few moments and so makes little difference. My bottom line would be on van price but that just says where I am coming from!
Andy

__________________


The Master

Status: Offline
Posts: 12473
Date:

It can take more than a couple of minutes Andy, and hard on the head and shoulders. Many times I haven't bothered if staying just the one night. If the weather turns I rush to get it down again rather than get the canvas wet. Then there is trying to get the clips back in place when its closed down, just about breaks my wrists. I have also had to put clamps on the outside to keep it in place.
Then of course if I don't put the top up I end up walking around doubled over.
With a hi top None of the above would be a problem.

__________________




Happy Wanderer    

Don't worry, Be Happy! 

Live! Like someone left the gate open

 

 

 



Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 1874
Date:

Happywanderer wrote:

It can take more than a couple of minutes Andy, and hard on the head and shoulders. Many times I haven't bothered if staying just the one night. If the weather turns I rush to get it down again rather than get the canvas wet. Then there is trying to get the clips back in place when its closed down, just about breaks my wrists. I have also had to put clamps on the outside to keep it in place.
Then of course if I don't put the top up I end up walking around doubled over.
With a hi top None of the above would be a problem.


 I agree with you 100% Marj. smile



__________________

 Cheers. Pam.

Safe and happy travels everyone.

 



Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 3332
Date:

Also how are the bed at the back compared to at front?
Ie kitchen at the back?
Think I'd prefer bed at the bed, that way Could leave it made up all time..
Also any one know the height of a high top?


__________________

The Drewsterz my band site

Milo Online  my personal site

Love what you do  Do what you Love!!   my motto in life !

 



Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 1619
Date:

Milo that is my thought too, it would be terribly difficult I imagine to have any sort of made up bed at the front. With the twin bed you could leave one as a bed and one as table and seat. It would be quite a thin bed though from the looks.



__________________

Janette



Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 3332
Date:

and most seem to be 1983- 90's etc 

maybe  i should just get a pop top....confuse



-- Edited by milo on Sunday 14th of October 2012 12:06:22 AM

__________________

The Drewsterz my band site

Milo Online  my personal site

Love what you do  Do what you Love!!   my motto in life !

 



Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 3332
Date:

every where i look , the pop tops are the cheaper units, hi tops are the dearest ,
only problem i see with a hi top is going thru my carport, don't know how high they are?confuse.gif?



__________________

The Drewsterz my band site

Milo Online  my personal site

Love what you do  Do what you Love!!   my motto in life !

 



Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 1619
Date:

The High tops are too high for underground shopping centre carparks too. Mine just barely gets in my local carpark.



__________________

Janette



Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 1874
Date:

milo wrote:

Also how are the bed at the back compared to at front?
Ie kitchen at the back?
Think I'd prefer bed at the bed, that way Could leave it made up all time..
Also any one know the height of a high top?


Milo, the hi-top Hi Ace is 2.6 mtrs high.

My Hi Ace Commuter is 2.285 mtrs high.

According to Toyotas website, the standard Hi Ace is I.980 mtrs high.

Hope this helps. Happy searching.

Cheers. Pam.

 



__________________

 Cheers. Pam.

Safe and happy travels everyone.

 



Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 3332
Date:

hmm,thanks Pam...
might be a pop top for me then, wont fit under my carport...
wonder how much the lifters would be? and will have to see
a pop top and try and pull them down..



__________________

The Drewsterz my band site

Milo Online  my personal site

Love what you do  Do what you Love!!   my motto in life !

 



Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 3332
Date:

if i got a hi ace high top, it would need to be under 8ft to fit under my carport,
id have to have my roller door taken off....
just measured it ... i could park it out the front,
but would prefer to park it out the back as i have heaps of room



__________________

The Drewsterz my band site

Milo Online  my personal site

Love what you do  Do what you Love!!   my motto in life !

 



Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 8735
Date:

My bed is permanently made up at the back Milo.  [ Check out Pics on the Forum. ]  I'm going to get the Airlifters. [ I'm 71, and have Emphysema, therefore, a breathing problem.]   At the moment I can still get the Pop-top up and down OK, [and that's with a large Solar panel on top,] but it would be a problem later on, when the breathing gets worse.

I decided on the Pop-top, 'cause with a Hi-top you have more wind-drag, therefore use more fuel.

Cheers,

Sheba.



-- Edited by Sheba on Friday 19th of October 2012 09:52:00 PM

__________________
An it harm none, do what you will.


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 3332
Date:

Darn all there high k's!!! Would a diesel be better than petrol? Particularly with the e10 confusion?

-- Edited by milo on Saturday 20th of October 2012 02:32:09 AM

__________________

The Drewsterz my band site

Milo Online  my personal site

Love what you do  Do what you Love!!   my motto in life !

 

Duh


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 3240
Date:

Travel Bug wrote:

Milo, the hi-top Hi Ace is 2.6 mtrs high.

My Hi Ace Commuter is 2.285 mtrs high.

According to Toyotas website, the standard Hi Ace is I.980 mtrs high.

Hope this helps. Happy searching.

Cheers. Pam.

 


 All the specs are shown on the Toyota website as Pam says Milo, but bear in mind that when the pop top if fitted they are even higher.

Also, early model Hi Ace are lower than the later models as the wheels are bigger (higher)......

I have the height of my High Ace as 2.1 metres written on a bit of paper on my visor to remind me of the clearance I need for underground car parks and booms, drive throughs (eg; Macca's, bottle shops etc) and usually try to park in open car parks.  You need to allow for a little bit to make sure also.   I got caught in one underground carpark where the entry height was ok as posted, but they had made modificatons inside with things on the roof (lighting/sprinklers etc) and hadn't changed the entry height sign.....Luckily I was able to weave my way out again missing said obstructions.....

 



__________________

Vic  - Mitsubishi Outlander and rear end tent....

 

 

 



 



Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 3332
Date:

hmmm,

 

i guess when the time comes ill have to see if i could get owners of the camper van

to try and see if it will fit..



-- Edited by milo on Saturday 20th of October 2012 09:07:39 PM

__________________

The Drewsterz my band site

Milo Online  my personal site

Love what you do  Do what you Love!!   my motto in life !

 



The Master

Status: Offline
Posts: 12473
Date:

The height of Myrtle is 2 metres WITHOUT the pop top pushed up. Would be close to another 50 or 60 cm with the pop top up.

__________________




Happy Wanderer    

Don't worry, Be Happy! 

Live! Like someone left the gate open

 

 

 



Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 3332
Date:

so i got 7 feet clearance when the roller door is up which is roughly 2.1 metres...
i got almost 8 ft if i take off the roller door...

__________________

The Drewsterz my band site

Milo Online  my personal site

Love what you do  Do what you Love!!   my motto in life !

 



The Master

Status: Offline
Posts: 12473
Date:

In that case milo, you would only just get in with a pop top. You would only have .1 of a metre clearance. If you are meaning 10 cm that would be 4 inch clearance.
Even with the roller door off you wouldn't get in with a hi top.

__________________




Happy Wanderer    

Don't worry, Be Happy! 

Live! Like someone left the gate open

 

 

 

1 2  >  Last»  | Page of 2  sorted by
 
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.

Tweet this page Post to Digg Post to Del.icio.us
Purchase Grey Nomad bumper stickers Read our daily column, the Nomad News The Grey Nomad's Guidebook