At the risk of opening a tin of worms, I'm just wondering how does one compare the quality of mattresses from different suppliers? We're shopping around for a couple of new (single) mattresses for our van. They're a non standard size so I've checked out what I think are the only custom Innerspring mattress suppliers in Perth, Mr Mattress and Makin Mattresses. We've looked at and tested mattresses from both with apparently identical specs (though I can't remember the spring gauge used by the first). They both have pocket springs with high density edge supports, are double sided and felt very similar when we tested them. Both manufacturers seem to have good reviews.
Mr Mattress quotes $500 each (8yr warranty) and Makin Mattresses $900 each (5yr warranty). Apart from the obvious price variation, the only difference I can see is Mr Mattress is local while Makin Mattresses are manufactured interstate (South Aust I think). Are there any Sandgropers out there that have been unhappy with their mattresses from Mr Mattress?
Cheers
John
Roy E said
10:02 AM Jun 8, 2018
John,
I have a 2016 Jayco Starcraft Outback with two single beds. It came new with good inner-sprung mattresses. I don't know what brand they are but sizes are 70cm wide by approx 202 cm long for one and 190 cm long for the other. Jayco won't be the only maker putting inner-sprung single mattresses in their vans so perhaps you might contact van agents and maybe, get a better price or more info.
Regards,
Roy.
reikioz said
10:02 AM Jun 8, 2018
Hi John,
I'm not from Perth, however I used to be in the bed business. I would suggest that the primary requirement to have is Pocket Spring. You generally should have a medium density spring and with all else being equal, ( which it seems to be ) buy the less expensive one .
Cheers,
Frank
EJP said
11:24 AM Jun 8, 2018
John. we have a 2005 Jayco Freedom poptop and changed our single bed original foam mattresses over for 2 custom made inner spring mattresses, approx. 190 x 70 cm x 20 and 205 x 70 x 20 cm through Jayco. We took the measurements to Jayco and picked up the mattresses about 2 weeks later. I don't know where Jayco get them made but the quality appears to be good. They are comfortable and supportive, particually with my wife's bad hip. I can't remember the price but they were under $200 each.
Regards EJP
Valkyrie01 said
12:56 PM Jun 8, 2018
Roy, Frank and EJP thanks for your input. I hadn't considered caravan manufacturers, I might give that a try. I am surprised that you mentioned your mattresses are only 70cm wide. Ours were 76cm and we found that was too narrow for comfort so I've widened the bases to 85cm, the max that I thought I could get away with, without unduly constricting the walkway between them. Of course first I had to "shrink" the cabinet that sits between them, not an easy job but it's done and we're happy with the result.
Cheers
John
EJP said
01:44 PM Jun 8, 2018
John, Jayco make to size. When I measured the mattresses up I made allowances to make the beds up, ie, to tuck blankets in etc (hate doonas). You should not have a problem with your sizes.
Regards EJP
Kebbin said
02:34 PM Jun 8, 2018
Jayco simply buy from a mattress manufacturer they do not make them. Sorry Valkyrie01 Im not Western Australian so Ill but out now.
villatranquilla said
07:10 PM Jun 8, 2018
Jayco at Cannington sent us direct to the factory when we wanted a new mattress which was made to our specifications - it was good to visit the factory showroom (can't remember exactly where it was) and when it was made we picked it up from Jayco - took about 2 weeks.
The factory also makes mattresses for all defence forces and we were given the option of a good quality mattress with a reduced height.
-- Edited by villatranquilla on Friday 8th of June 2018 07:14:30 PM
Happywanderer said
01:38 PM Jun 9, 2018
Because of the unusual size of my mattress 100x170 or 1000 x 1700.
Had a mattress made by The Sandman in Geelong for $269.00
dazz49 said
08:20 PM Jun 9, 2018
Hi. Just replaced my queen size in the van with a Makin Matilda.. Made to measure. Cost me $1200. Wished I had replaced it two years ago. Recommend but no affiliation. Cheers Daz
Valkyrie01 said
01:42 AM Jun 10, 2018
Thanks Dazz and all others. $1200 vs $900 each for two smallish singles from Makin Mattresses, not a lot of difference it seems with this manufacturer. I'll check out the local Jayco dealer as a point of reference to my current quotes.
Cheers
John
Valkyrie01 said
01:46 AM Jun 10, 2018
Meant to say $1200 (queen size) vs $900 each for two smallish singles. I could get a queen size mattress and cut it in half and prbly still be in front ;)
Cheers
the rocket said
11:36 AM Jun 10, 2018
We bought our mattresses from clark rubber For our previous caravan Nowhere near prices you quoted and found them good. Put there egg shell foam on top. (The foam with the ten year warranty) i think we bought the queen size egg shell foam and got them to cut in half. Check sizes u need n u may b able to do the same. Good luck.
-- Edited by the rocket on Sunday 10th of June 2018 11:41:04 AM
Valkyrie01 said
03:29 PM Jun 10, 2018
G'day, sounds like your mattress is/was a foam one?? We're looking for innerspring ones, specifically made with pocket springs and that's the reason for the higher prices but I'm surprised by the variations between manufacturers. That's the reason for my original post; what shortcuts or dodgey materials might be used in the cheaper quote or is the higher quote just excessive?
Cheers
the rocket said
04:32 PM Jun 10, 2018
Valkyrie01 wrote:
G'day, sounds like your mattress is/was a foam one?? We're looking for innerspring ones, specifically made with pocket springs and that's the reason for the higher prices but I'm surprised by the variations between manufacturers. That's the reason for my original post; what shortcuts or dodgey materials might be used in the cheaper quote or is the higher quote just excessive? Cheers
Hi valkyrie01, our mattresses were innerspring. usually bed manufacturers will show u a sample of the mattress inside so u can compare. Good luck.
Dave1952 said
09:45 AM Jun 11, 2018
Camec also sell dedicated caravan mattresses, as do, I think, Caravav RV Camping.
BrianR said
01:35 PM Jun 11, 2018
We had a queen mattress made in two halves with cover pads of different density made by Mr Mattress.
We are living permanently in the van.
It would rate up there with all the high quality we have bought over the years for sleeping.
Could not fault the service or quality. And the sleep is brilliant. :)
Valkyrie01 said
11:41 AM Jun 12, 2018
Hi Brian thanks for your input re: Mr Mattress and also to thanks to all contributors. I'm going to give the local guy (MM) a try this time. Wifey talked me out of looking at Jayco's offerings due to current (quality) issues a lot of people seem to be experiencing with caravan manufacturers.
Cheers
John
At the risk of opening a tin of worms, I'm just wondering how does one compare the quality of mattresses from different suppliers? We're shopping around for a couple of new (single) mattresses for our van. They're a non standard size so I've checked out what I think are the only custom Innerspring mattress suppliers in Perth, Mr Mattress and Makin Mattresses. We've looked at and tested mattresses from both with apparently identical specs (though I can't remember the spring gauge used by the first). They both have pocket springs with high density edge supports, are double sided and felt very similar when we tested them. Both manufacturers seem to have good reviews.
Mr Mattress quotes $500 each (8yr warranty) and Makin Mattresses $900 each (5yr warranty). Apart from the obvious price variation, the only difference I can see is Mr Mattress is local while Makin Mattresses are manufactured interstate (South Aust I think). Are there any Sandgropers out there that have been unhappy with their mattresses from Mr Mattress?
Cheers
John
I have a 2016 Jayco Starcraft Outback with two single beds. It came new with good inner-sprung mattresses. I don't know what brand they are but sizes are 70cm wide by approx 202 cm long for one and 190 cm long for the other. Jayco won't be the only maker putting inner-sprung single mattresses in their vans so perhaps you might contact van agents and maybe, get a better price or more info.
Regards,
Roy.
I'm not from Perth, however I used to be in the bed business. I would suggest that the primary requirement to have is Pocket Spring. You generally should have a medium density spring and with all else being equal, ( which it seems to be ) buy the less expensive one .
Cheers,
Frank
Regards EJP
Jayco at Cannington sent us direct to the factory when we wanted a new mattress which was made to our specifications - it was good to visit the factory showroom (can't remember exactly where it was) and when it was made we picked it up from Jayco - took about 2 weeks.
The factory also makes mattresses for all defence forces and we were given the option of a good quality mattress with a reduced height.
-- Edited by villatranquilla on Friday 8th of June 2018 07:14:30 PM
Had a mattress made by The Sandman in Geelong for $269.00
We bought our mattresses from clark rubber For our previous caravan Nowhere near prices you quoted and found them good. Put there egg shell foam on top. (The foam with the ten year warranty) i think we bought the queen size egg shell foam and got them to cut in half. Check sizes u need n u may b able to do the same. Good luck.
-- Edited by the rocket on Sunday 10th of June 2018 11:41:04 AM
Hi valkyrie01, our mattresses were innerspring. usually bed manufacturers will show u a sample of the mattress inside so u can compare. Good luck.
We are living permanently in the van.
It would rate up there with all the high quality we have bought over the years for sleeping.
Could not fault the service or quality. And the sleep is brilliant. :)